GMAT Critical Reasoning and Outside Knowledge

Does any official GMAT Critical Reasoning question demand outside knowledge?  The frustrating answer to this question is: for the most part, no, but in a way, yes.  I will explain.

Self-contained

It is absolutely true that if a GMAT CR question concerns, say, toxins in wood smoke, you need to know absolutely nothing about the biochemistry of wood smoke in order to answer the question.  If the CR questions concerns, say, the polygraph test, you need to know absolutely nothing about how the polygraph test operates or how reliable it is in order to answer the question.  Every GMAT CR question is self-contained, in that one needs no outside knowledge about that particular subject matter in order to answer the question.  That is 100% true.

Real world situation

Unfortunately, GMAT students who hear that true statement make the unfortunate incorrect generalization: all outside knowledge is irrelevant to the Critical Reasoning.   This is a profound misunderstanding.

Think about why the GMAT has Critical Reasoning in the first place.  The GMAT wants to know if student can understand arguments precisely because managers in the business world have to understand all sorts of arguments all the time.  Fundamentally, any sales pitch is an argument.  Any business may have to hear and analyze arguments from its suppliers, its customers, its advertisers, its partners and affiliates, its investors, its insurance company, etc. etc.   All of these would be real-world arguments, and an intelligent manager is very good at hearing these arguments and discerning: should I believe this argument or not?  what are they assuming?  what information would allow me to evaluate whether they are correct?  etc.  In other words, all the GMAT CR skills are skills that an actual manager might have to apply in analyzing real world arguments.

Toward this end, many of the GMAT CR arguments have a “real world” feel to them.  Even if the actual company or location is fictional (such as “Parland”), the interests and motivations of the people described in the argument are very much like those of folks in analogous situation in the real world.  Having a sense of what would be realistic or not realistic in the analogous real world situations can be very helpful in figuring out GMAT CR.

Real world knowledge

Of course, one cannot become an expert in every conceivable situation and sector, but that’s not necessary.  In order to gain an edge, one simply has to have a general sense of the interest and motivations of people in real world situation, especially in the business world.  For example, what are real world reasons that a company would or would not choose a particular supplier?  What are real world reasons that customers would buy or not buy a particular product?  How is it different for different products?  What motivates politicians, scientists, union members, marketers, home owners, policemen, criminals, etc.?  What are the factors that can make a business succeed or fail?  What makes some business only mildly successful and other similar businesses wildly successful?

All this reading will build your Reading Comprehension skills, and if you look at the grammar of individual sentences, it will help your Sentence Correction skills.  If you read all these sources regularly, you will build intuition for the push and pull of real world forces, and this intuition will serve you extremely well on GMAT CR.  In fact, all of those sources will be full of real world arguments: sometimes the authors or editors make an argument of their own, but often objective articles present real world business people making arguments of various kinds.  When you find these arguments, practice all the standard GMAT CR analyses on them: what would strengthen or weaken them?  what is the assumption?  what can we infer?  what further information would allow you to evaluate the conclusion?  If one person presents an argument, and another person responds, what does that response do to the first person’s argument?  If you become skilled at analyzing real world arguments, then GMAT CR arguments will seem like child’s play to you.

Primer

As a “head start” into all this real world reading, I have prepared a few articles about basic real world issues that could help you in thinking about a variety of GMAT CR questions.

Economics: Supply and Demand

Economics: Labor and Wages

Economics: Inflation, unemployment, and interest rates

Law: “beyond any reasonable doubt”

Statistics: Statistical significance

Economics: Profit and Non-profits

Statistics: Populations

Statistics: Medical Trials and the Placebo Effect

Those blogs are introductions to topics.  Through further reading, you could go much deeper with any one of them.

Summary

While you don’t need to be an expert in anything to answer GMAT CR, you do need to have a well-honed sense of how the real world works — especially a keen sense of the modern business world.   If you have had experiences reading the WSJ, Bloomberg, or the Economist, or your have found other sources that have deepened your real world knowledge, please let us know in the comments sections below!

2 Responses to GMAT Critical Reasoning and Outside Knowledge

1. Prasanna Thawait July 4, 2019 at 11:22 pm #

It is true that we should have a real-world business sense if we want to pursue our career in this field. Great post.

2. solitaryreaper September 19, 2015 at 1:12 am #

Dear Mike !
That’s an awesome piece of work. Kudos to you 🙂

Magoosh blog comment policy: To create the best experience for our readers, we will only approve comments that are relevant to the article, general enough to be helpful to other students, concise, and well-written! 😄 Due to the high volume of comments across all of our blogs, we cannot promise that all comments will receive responses from our instructors.

We highly encourage students to help each other out and respond to other students' comments if you can!

If you are a Premium Magoosh student and would like more personalized service from our instructors, you can use the Help tab on the Magoosh dashboard. Thanks!